Shopping Cart

Free domestic shipping for orders over $130, plus FREE instant exchanges. Click here for more info.

JC Cookie Cutters

Accessory - $8

For the first time you can make cupcake cookies! This Cookie Cutter Pack comes complete with 2 shaped cookie cutter (featuring the famous Johnny Cupcakes Crossbones Logo and mascot- Big Kid!) There is also a special recipe on the back from our very own customer, Amy Sertl!

For best results:
1: Cut out shape
2: Place on baking sheet
3: Imprint dough with cookie stamp

Make sure to hand wash for a good time!


You have 45 days after delivery to return anything you’re unhappy with. We offer free instant exchanges for customers in the domestic US- meaning a new order will be processed even before you send back the return.

*Exceptions include items marked as final sale.

Learn more here.